Scott Morrison said 40 cargo ships were being prevented from delivering supplies to Australia by industrial action. Is that correct? – ABC News


CoronaCheck is RMIT ABC Fact Checks weekly email newsletter devoted to combating the misinformation infodemic surrounding the coronavirus outbreak.You can read the most recent edition below, and sign up for have the next newsletter provided directly to your inbox.CoronaCheck # 42In this weeks newsletter, weve utilized marine tracking websites to check a claim made by Prime Minister Scott Morrison that 40 ships, some carrying important medical supplies, were “lined up” at Port Botany as industrial action prevented them from dumping at the port.Weve likewise looked at the stats around psychological health in Victoria, as well as the UK, which is fighting a second wave of COVID-19. Were boats with medical supplies avoided from discharging in Sydney?As the pandemic puts worldwide supply chains at danger, Prime Minister Scott Morrison has actually claimed medical stocks were being delayed by industrial action on Sydneys waterside, with “militant” unions avoiding 40 ships from dumping at Port Botany.”There are 40 ships, and Im informed theres some 90,000 containers out there. That includes medical products,” Mr Morrison informed reporters on September 29, referring to a pay conflict in between the Maritime Union of Australia and port terminal operator Patrick.”You can decrease to Port Botany or down to Kurnell and take a look out there and you can see them lining up, and each and every single one of them lining up is being held back from Australians getting what they need”. Port Botany is indeed experiencing delays, which Patrick blames on “strikes, go slows and work restrictions” and the union blames on management decisions.But were 40 ships lined up, as Mr Morrison claimed?Fact Check has actually reviewed information from the site MarineTracker.com, which records the motion of ships using an onboard recognition system that all container ships carry when transiting Port Botany.The information reveals just seven container ships waiting or getting here off the coast over the 24 hours to Mr Morrisons news conference.Four of the seven ships were yet to dock when Mr Morrison made his claim, with 3 of them eventually waiting between two and five days.On the very same day, Patrick Terminals claimed 38 ships were “being held up around Australia and en path from Asia”. Even if thats the case, those boats, some as far off as the Philippines, were definitely not noticeable from Port Botany.Meanwhile, the industry group Shipping Australia stated hold-ups at the port had resulted in ships not waiting however “bypassing New South Wales” entirely.Associate Professor Vinh Thai, of RMIT Universitys supply chain and logistics school, informed Fact Check that shipping hold-ups had many causes, such as weather-related aspects, devices breakdown or industrial action, and apportioning blame was not always straightforward.But he said port blockage could have “multiplier effects”, as ports lose company and shipping lines pass on the expenses of hold-ups and of re-routing freight, eventually implying customers pay higher rates for goods.Was supply of medicines impacted?Of course, hold-ups do not necessarily mean shortages, and last week Medicines Australia CEO Elizabeth de Somer, who represents the nations pharmaceutical business, stated that while delays made it more difficult to handle medication stocks, there were “no lacks related to this [commercial] action at the moment”– in part since stocks had actually been diverted to other ports or air freight.”There are shortages of medications unassociated to COVID-19, and unassociated to this specific action,” she stated. “There are lots of factors that can trigger medications to go into short supply.”In an email to Fact Check, the Governments Therapeutic Goods Administration stated numerous companies had formally raised concerns about the impact of shipping hold-ups on medical supply chains.”Companies have actually indicated that while there is no immediate influence on medication materials, there is potential for the commercial action to considerably delay products of medications into Australia,” it said.Stay up-to-date on the coronavirus outbreakThe statistics on psychological health and COVID-19As Melburnians enter their third month of phase 4 limitations, the lockdowns toll on psychological health continues to stress health experts.What does the information show?If you or anybody you understand requirements assist: The ABC has actually reported that Victorian Department of Health and Human Services data exposes a 33 percent increase in the variety of children providing to healthcare facility with self-harm injuries in the six weeks to August 8 compared to the exact same time last year. The figures revealed a 9.3 per cent boost in presentations for all age groups.Statistics from the crisis assistance network LifeLine also reflect the pandemics toll. According to the ABC, the hotline had received 25 percent more requires the year to August compared to 2019. A Melbourne Institute report has actually found that young Australians are doing it tough, with 23 per cent reporting high rates of psychological distress– more than twice the rate reported before COVID-19.”Data from the Taking the Pulse of the Nation survey show that, throughout autumn, young Victorians reported rates of psychological distress that were comparable to those of young Australians in other states,” the researchers kept in mind.”The reports diverged in July, with the share of young Victorians reporting high levels of psychological distress being 28 percent (5 percentage points higher than the share found in other states). The exact same shares were reported in August.”Interestingly, the report noted that falling COVID-19 infections in Victoria throughout September corresponded with a drop in mental distress amongst young Victorians.Despite these concerning patterns, Victoria has actually not experienced an increase in suicides overall throughout the pandemic.Data released by the Victorian Coroners Court this week shows that there were 530 suicides in the state to September 30, compared to 534 to the exact same point last year. There has been, however, a rise in the number of young boys suiciding, with 13 boys under the age of 18 taking their lives up until now this year, the very same number as for all of 2019. Fact checking COVID-19 in the UKAs a 2nd wave of COVID-19 cleans over the UK, with average brand-new cases increasing above 10,000 a week, fact checkers have actually fought a fresh stream of false information about the virus, lockdowns and preventative steps such as using masks.Take, for instance, a claim debunked by Full Fact that challenging an individual for not using a mask could see you fined under the Equality Act 2010.”This is not correct,” the fact checkers reported. “Asking somebody to wear a face covering is not likely to be discrimination, as long as you follow federal government assistance.”Meanwhile, Reuters found that the rise in cases in the UK was not evidence that face masks are inefficient. Rather, it was most likely driven by the easing of coronavirus restrictions.Full Fact likewise took aim at news stories stating that “official information” showed restaurants and clubs “caused less than 3 per cent of coronavirus infections in the week before the 10pm curfew”.”This is a misreading of information which only covers clusters and outbreaks where more than someone is or has believed to have a respiratory infection,” they found.”This data does not always verify where a new case was gotten.”Misinformation about COVID-19 deaths has likewise been spread in the UK, with Full Fact discrediting one social media post which declared the virus eliminated fewer individuals than obesity.According to a 2017 quote by Public Health England, obesity was accountable for around 30,000 deaths a year, while at the time of Full Facts investigation more than 37,000 people in England (and 42,000 throughout the UK) had actually passed away of COVID-19 in the previous 6 months.From Washington, D.C.US President Donald Trump was last week identified with COVID-19 after months of playing down the seriousness of the illness and simply 2 weeks after declaring at an election rally that the coronavirus “affects practically nobody”. In the minutes, hours and days following the medical diagnosis, rumours and conspiracies have spread out online, from claims Mr Trump was fabricating his illness to score political points, to suggestions his challengers had deliberately contaminated him.Fact checkers at Lead Stories were fast to debunk one viral tweet that supposed to reveal pictures of Mr Trump using a portable oxygen tank as he boarded his helicopter en path to the Walter Reed Medical Centre to get treatment.”Pretty sure Trump boarded Marine One with a portable oxygen concentrator in his pocket with the nasal cannula going up his back, concealed in his hair and tucked under his mask,” the tweet read, alongside images.”He is not in addition to they state. Phony in chief.”But a video analysis by Lead Stories discovered that the “cannula” pointed to by the tweeter was likely just Mr Trumps hair, without any proof of a wire extending into his mask.The fact checkers were likewise not able to find for sale any portable oxygen concentrators little enough to fit discreetly into the pocket of a fit jacket.Meanwhile, PolitiFact deemed Mr Trumps project had actually not requested for donations to aid his medical treatment, and that the so-called “Doomsday Plane”– a mobile command centre to keep US authorities in touch with marine nuclear forces in times of crisis– is, in fact, regularly seen in the skies above the capital and had actually not taken flight in reaction to the Presidents diagnosis.In other newsIn what is probably the platforms most difficult attempt yet at punishing misinformation, Facebook this week revealed it would ban and get rid of any Facebook pages and groups, in addition to any Instagram accounts, representing QAnon conspiracy theories.The move comes two months after the company stated it was prohibiting QAnon accounts, groups and pages promoting violence, a policy it says resulted in the elimination of more than 1,500 pages and groups.”Weve been alert in implementing our policy and studying its influence on the platform however weve seen several problems that resulted in todays upgrade,” Facebook said in a blog site post on Wednesday.”For example, while weve eliminated QAnon material that supports and celebrates violence, weve seen other QAnon content connected to various kinds of genuine world harm, consisting of current claims that the west coast wildfires were begun by specific groups, which diverted attention of regional officials from fighting the fires and safeguarding the general public.”But some state the restriction has actually come too late.As online misinformation reporter Cam Wilson composed in an article for Gizmodo, Facebooks choice comes “years after QAnon has actually been extensively reported as a major issue”.”QAnon believers have actually supposedly killed people. Theyre a huge source of false information. They bug individuals en masse. And thats even prior to you think about individuals whove lost spouses, family and buddies to the radicalising forces of a Facebook-fuelled conspiracy theory.”Meanwhile, Alex Newhouse from the Centre on Terrorism, Extremism and Counterterrorism at the Middlebury Institute in Califronia tweeted that the “best time to have actually banned QAnon was in 2017”.”The second-best time is now, with the most essential stretch of the election project ahead of us. Facebooks de-platforming of QAnon will eliminate one of the most dangerous sources of disinformation if implemented efficiently.”Edited by Ellen McCutchan, with thanks to David Campbell, Katie Johnson and Sonam ThomasGot a fact that requires monitoring? Tweet us @ABCFactCheck or send us an email at [email protected] content was originally published here.

CoronaCheck is RMIT ABC Fact Checks weekly email newsletter dedicated to fighting the false information infodemic surrounding the coronavirus outbreak.You can check out the most current edition listed below, and subscribe to have the next newsletter delivered straight to your inbox.CoronaCheck # 42In this weeks newsletter, weve used marine tracking websites to examine a claim made by Prime Minister Scott Morrison that 40 ships, some bring essential medical products, were “lined up” at Port Botany as industrial action prevented them from unloading at the port.Weve likewise looked at the statistics around psychological health in Victoria, as well as the UK, which is battling a second wave of COVID-19. Fact checking COVID-19 in the UKAs a 2nd wave of COVID-19 cleans over the UK, with average new cases rising above 10,000 a week, fact checkers have battled a fresh stream of false information about the virus, lockdowns and preventative procedures such as wearing masks.Take, for example, a claim unmasked by Full Fact that challenging an individual for not using a mask could see you fined under the Equality Act 2010.”This is not correct,” the truth checkers reported.”Misinformation about COVID-19 deaths has actually also been spread out in the UK, with Full Fact discrediting one social media post which declared the infection killed less individuals than obesity.According to a 2017 price quote by Public Health England, weight problems was accountable for around 30,000 deaths a year, while at the time of Full Facts examination more than 37,000 individuals in England (and 42,000 across the UK) had actually passed away of COVID-19 in the previous six months.From Washington, D.C.US President Donald Trump was last week detected with COVID-19 after months of playing down the severity of the illness and just two weeks after declaring at an election rally that the coronavirus “affects virtually no one”.”But a video analysis by Lead Stories discovered that the “cannula” pointed to by the tweeter was likely just Mr Trumps hair, with no evidence of a wire extending into his mask.The fact checkers were likewise unable to find for sale any portable oxygen concentrators little enough to fit quietly into the pocket of a suit jacket.Meanwhile, PolitiFact deemed Mr Trumps project had actually not asked for contributions to assist his medical treatment, and that the so-called “Doomsday Plane”– a mobile command centre to keep US authorities in touch with naval nuclear forces in times of crisis– is, in reality, frequently seen in the skies above the capital and had actually not taken flight in response to the Presidents diagnosis.In other newsIn what is arguably the platforms toughest attempt yet at splitting down on misinformation, Facebook this week revealed it would prohibit and remove any Facebook groups and pages, as well as any Instagram accounts, representing QAnon conspiracy theories.The move comes two months after the company stated it was prohibiting QAnon groups, pages and accounts promoting violence, a policy it says led to the removal of more than 1,500 pages and groups.


Related Post